A Stranger Among Us: A Gatsby Era Interactive Murder Mystery
- When
- America/New_York (EDT)
- Where
- Bottlebrush Gallery & Center for the Arts539 Main Street, Harmony, PA 16037
Tickets are sold on Eventbrite. We link straight to the listing — nothing is bought here. Listing details come from the source and can change. Eventovia indexes events; it does not organize them or sell tickets. Terms & Disclaimer
This event has passed
It took place 5 days ago. See upcoming nightlife & clubbing in New Castle
A Stranger Among Us: A Gatsby Era Interactive Murder Mystery took place on Sat, Oct 17, 2026 at 6:00 PM (EDT) at Bottlebrush Gallery & Center for the Arts in New Castle, PA.
About this event
Experience a mysterious Gatsby-era evening filled with intrigue at the haunted Bottlebrush Gallery. Visitors will explore the gallery's atmosphere while enjoying an immersive night of suspense.
Full description from organizerShow less
Join us for an evening of mystery and intrigue in Gatsby era style at the haunted Bottlebrush Gallery in Harmony! Dress in your finest 1930s Art Deco Glamour and enjoy an evening of cocktails, hors d'oeuvres, scandal and murder. A Stranger Among Us: An Interactive Gatsby Style Murder Mystery Evening The year is 1930-something, and an intriguing stranger has just rolled into town. No one knows exactly who he is, where he came from or why he is here. There were only two things that the people really knew about Herman Baker: he was concealing secrets and someone in town has a very good reason to want him dead. But who killed him? Was it the jealous lover? The disgruntled business associate? The charming socialite with something to hide? Or perhaps someone no one suspects at all? Tonight, you won’t simply watch the mystery—you’ll become part of it. The cast will mingle throughout the evening, moving among the guests, revealing clues, sharing secrets, stirring up suspicions, and perhaps telling a few lies along the way. As the night progresses, you’ll have the opportunity to question suspects, uncover hidden motives, piece together clues, and decide who you believe is telling the truth. Keep your eyes open. Listen carefully. Trust no one. Because the killer may be standing right beside you. The question isn’t simply, “Whodunit?” It’s: “Can YOU figure it out before the night is over?” Schedule of Events: 6:00-6:50pm Cocktail Hour, Mix and Mingle: Get to know the characters. 7:00-7:50pm Heavy Hors d'oeuvres & Finger Foods: Find the clues, question suspects, make your guess on whodunnit. 8-8:30pm Dessert: The killer is revealed! Your ticket price of $45 includes: complimentary glass of wine (21+ and over) or na beverage, hors d'oeuvers, dessert and the show. No refunds.
Keep going
All New Castle events →Similar events
View all →Details
- When
- Sat, Oct 17, 2026 · 6:00 PM (EDT)
- Where
- Bottlebrush Gallery & Center for the Arts
- Address
- 539 Main Street, Harmony, PA 16037
- Price
- $45 +
- Genre
- 105/party or social gathering
Questions
- When was A Stranger Among Us: A Gatsby Era Interactive Murder Mystery?
- Sat, Oct 17, 2026 at 6:00 PM EDT.
- Where was A Stranger Among Us: A Gatsby Era Interactive Murder Mystery?
- Bottlebrush Gallery & Center for the Arts, 539 Main Street, Harmony, PA 16037, New Castle, PA.



